Yeah I liked Pinkie Pried, and nope, not because of Weird Al, it's because they finally showed Pinkie as a character after many episodes of butchering her personality turning her into a joke machine, it was a great come back for a fantastic pony. Also her son was great.
Kicks_McGee - 10 years ago
Sad to see PTS part 1 and the hilarious Simple Ways below the decidedly meh Rainbow Falls and Daring Don't, but oh well. Pinkie Pride definitely deserves its spot. I just hope Leap of Faith does well in the next poll - it's one of my favorite S4 episodes because it's the kind of good solid focus episode AJ deserved for so long.
Silvera - 10 years ago
@Anonymous: Oh, you were talking to/about me. I didn't know. Thought it was someone else as I'm called Silvera. But no, I don't hate Pinkie Pride, I just said it was a very overrated episode and it's sad to see how underrated episodes do and how people only votes for episodes that has popular ponies. But I still love all the episodes, just think certain ones is totally overrated. And I'm a GIRL, so it's SHE, not he!
Nucleus Brain - 10 years ago
Gaaaahhhh i hate Pinkie Pride.
Voted for Rarity takes Manehatten.
silvermarsh - 10 years ago
Pinkie Apple Pie was easily my favorite of the season. It was so lovable.
Not surprising that Pinkie Pride is winning though.
Sad to see Simple Ways so down low as I loved that one.
The only two that I disliked (out of the first half of S4) were Daring Don't and Power Ponies. To be fair though I think Power Ponies might be growing on me.
Audunis - 10 years ago
Pinkie Pride winning was likely but Bats! in second?
Oh right, it had Fluttershy turn into a bat and therefore it was so kawaii.
Even if it was pretty lame.
Gypsy Teller - 10 years ago
personally, i like threes a crowd because my little sis is busy alot with college and work so its rare that i see her anymore. and when i do, someone always butts in. its just funny that my life can be seen through ponies. but that one aside (and because i'm blind as tartarus and didn't see it) pinkie pride is my favorite. pinkie learned an important lesson about letting your ego take over, something ELSE i can relate to.
rusticware - 10 years ago
@namelessNP
I'll proudly state that its mine. A much better musical then MMC was, cause it didn't have the baggage of having to tell a "meaningful" story integral to a MAJOR change for a series main character thus it could just have FUN. An insightful look into just how deep Pinkie is as a character. A great new character introduction in Cheese Sandwich presented masterfully by Weird Al. All the other ponies had a small or subtle role to play that was filled perfectly by their character without it being overbearing and having all mane 6 together in an episode "just because" (a thing i felt season 4 suffered greatly from). Weird Al's prescience was honestly just the cherry on top. I feel the episode would have still been carried had he not been able to fulfill the role specifically written for him. Him actually being able to do the episode was awesome but not necessarily the thing that makes the episode so good imo.
NamelessNP - 10 years ago
No surprise here
I wouldn't be surprised if Pinkie Pride won favorite episode for the entire series.
Matt - 10 years ago
What is happening right now? Wasn't Pinkie Pride pretty much the most beloved episode of the fandom. What happened? Why now that it's getting the votes it deserves, people are suddenly ready to call bullshit. I thought it was pretty common knowledge that Pinkie Pride was probably the best of Season 4 and maybe the best of the show, but what's this? People are actually supporting the episode and showing how great it really was? BLASPHEMY! Sometimes I just don't understand you people.
Anonymous - 10 years ago
MRRFRHFFRFHHHHFFFFFF... you know what makes you bronies different by the haters? NOTHING. I hope with all my heart that the end of Hub Network, will make the fifth season the last one so once it's over this terrible nightmare will finally end and the show will be finally free from people like you that prefer to be devoted to an overrated woman instead of enjoy the show itself. You bronies are nothing but a bunch of monsters.
Medicine Cat - 10 years ago
Torn again. I was sorely tempted to vote for "Bats!" if only for, "Fruit bat roundup! Fruit bat roundup!". But I have a thing for underponies in general and particularly for Daring Do. . .
On a not-so-general note, I really do wish people could leave the obscenities at the door when they come here. It is a MLP/FIM fan site, not Grand Theft Auto. It's wholly uncalled for, and there are kids here.
Badly Drawn Turtle - 10 years ago
@Anonymous
first; you may want to spell-check comments before posting. It goes a long way to making you look less like an idiot.
Second; regardless of who you know, the "@" symbol is generally used to address someone who has already commented on the page; when you use it to address someone who hasn't commented, it's like starting up a conversation with someone who isn't in the room. Hence people get confused. (No, assuming that the person with a similar display name to someone you know is actually the person you know is not a valid excuse. That's an entirely separate mistake.)
Third; although I don't like people who hate on episodes either, you are currently the most vitriolic commenter on this page. That isn't a good thing.
Fourth: "Traitor"
I don't think that word means what you think it means.
Fifth; when you called "Pinkie Pride" the (second) most loved episode, you were referring to which objective measure or comprehensive poll? Claiming that since it's your favorite episode it's therefore almost everyone's favorite episode is illogical, rude, and wrong.
Bonus sixth; I would say that any episode which leads by 20% in one of these polls is overrated, simply because the "good" and "bad" episodes aren't that far apart in quality overall.
Anonymous - 10 years ago
@David: What is this, the "Pinkie Pride sucks day" or something? I know who is that Silvera, he hates it, and I see many people here hates it. How shaming, I don't want to read what do you write you traytors.
David - 10 years ago
@Anonymous: There's no one called silver-rain here, who are yo talking to?
I think you're being a jerk by the way. People aren't made to accept everything, we're not inhuman. And don't tell anyone to leave the fandom when they don't like something, that means you must leave too. It doesn't work that way and you should accept the fact that people hates. And you assume when people say an episode is overrated it their most hated episode? I think Pinkie Pride is overrated too, but it's far from my most hated.
Abraman - 10 years ago
Hmmm, what should I vote for...
Oh, Pinkie Pride is in this poll! My opinion doesn't matter!
Mojo - 10 years ago
There's pretty much nothing to bats but a big gimmick, why is it so high.
And Simple Ways really shouldn't be behind freaking Daring Don't.
Nightmare_Shinigami - 10 years ago
I think "Pinkie Pried" gets WAY to much love from this Fandom. Don't get me wrong, it's still a good Episode, but I think the main Reasons why so many like this is Cheese Sandwich being voiced by Weird Al (which is in my Eyes a weak reason to like a Episode), the Songs (which I don't like, except for Pinkie's Lament) and Pinkie not being portrayed as a Joke-Character (which is a good Thing, but it still gets overshadowed by her portrayal in other Episodes (Filly Vanilli)
On a bright Side, my most hated Episode is the second least Favorite of this Poll
Anonymous - 10 years ago
@Silver_rain: it's not overrated, it's you that are an butthurter and you can't accept that your most hated episode is the (second) most loved episode of the show. If you can't accept this fact, leave this site and the fandom.
anon2 - 10 years ago
It seems no matter what, we'll always have a few haters. Even Luna, Fluttershy, Canterlot Wedding, any aspect or part of the fandom is going to have people who decry it as the worst thing. We'll probably always have anti-bronies, too. Doesn't matter though. What's good will still be good :)
Silvera - 10 years ago
Pinkie Pride is seriously a VERY overrated episode.
Rockpath5 - 10 years ago
@Golnar
Fuck that.
MichaelTS0148 - 10 years ago
Castle Mane-ia is a mediocre episode at best; why is it so high on the list?
Golnar - 10 years ago
Don't say fuck
Golnar - 10 years ago
I vote for pinkie pride, but I also like daring don't and princess twilight sparkle
apparently - 10 years ago
What the fuck is this fandom's obsession with musical episodes? Do people really enjoy having the plot spoon-fed to them with rushed, unmemorable songs?
Golnar - 10 years ago
As soon as I herd that there was a season 4 of my little pony friendship is magic I started to watch every single episode
Jube - 10 years ago
And of course all my favourites except Pinkie Pride are in the bottom :[
Peter Erick - 10 years ago
P-Pride because it was released a day b-4 my bday
Jube - 10 years ago
This first half of the season had so many 5 star episodes imo. Such as Princess Twilight Sparkle, Daring Don't, Rainbow Falls, Three's a Crowd, Pinkie Pride and Simple Ways.
My current favourite would propably have to be Simple Ways or Three's a Crowd
Jube - 10 years ago
This first half of the season had so many 5 star episodes imo. Such as Princess Twilight Sparkle, Daring Don't, Rainbow Falls, Three's a Crowd, Pinkie Pride and Simple Ways.
My current favourite would propably have to be Simple Ways or Three's a Crowd
Pegagamer - 10 years ago
I voted for Pinkie Pride, because WEIRD AL!
Brony15 - 10 years ago
Adam Burt, Twilight is your fav? *brohoof* :D
Brony15 - 10 years ago
Dashie24, don't worry, I don't hate Rainbow Falls either. :) It's gteat. And RD, and Derpy made it.
I like Pinkie Pride more, though. But that's just a matter of taste.
ShadowRose - 10 years ago
Huh? WHY do people hate Daring Don't more than Rainbow Falls? Rainbow Falls is the worst candidate on the list, in my opinion.
Rockpath5 - 10 years ago
Pinkie Pride is my second favorite episode of the series. Pinkie Apple Pie was my favorite episode though, so that got my vote. I can't believe Bats! is in second place. It had nothing going for it except the fact that it introduced Flutterbat, a source of most of the good season 4 fan art.
Adam Burt - 10 years ago
Where the finale? I pick Pinkie Pride cos it's fun and like Cheese Sandwhich. Like Rainbow Falls, abit cos Derpy show up and Power Ponies, cos I'm into Superheroes. Like Princess Twilight Sparkle cos Twilight is my favorite out of the Mane 6.
Dashie24 - 10 years ago
I voted Rainbow Falls because I really enjoyed the episode and Dash was hilarious in it! I wish it wasn't so hated though. *sigh* :(
Badly Drawn Turtle - 10 years ago
Huh, I didn't realize that "Pinkie Pride" was so popular. I didn't actually like it all that much; I'm not sure why. My vote goes to "Pinkie Apple Pie". It was a relatively straightforward story, which allowed it to have a nice, slow pace focused on character-interaction. At least, in my view. Or maybe it's because I really liked the song.
MichaelTS0148 - 10 years ago
OH GODDAMNIT, I DIDN'T SEE PINKIE PRIDE THERE AND ENDED UP VOTING FOR RARITY TAKES MANEHATTEN.
Eh, it's okay; it's clearly winning, anyways.
Matt - 10 years ago
Is this even a contest? Pinkie Pride's gonna win by a landslide. But man, Season 4 was so frickin good
Anonymous - 10 years ago
Man this round... With the exception of Rainbow Falls (0 stars) and Simple Ways (4 stars) all those episodes are 5 stars episodes in my eyes... But like others said, I'll go with the best one: Pinkie Pride of course!
Zebugamer45 - 10 years ago
Oh my!!! So much good episodes!! It's hard to choose D: Oh well, I love Cheese sandwich :p
Yeah I liked Pinkie Pried, and nope, not because of Weird Al, it's because they finally showed Pinkie as a character after many episodes of butchering her personality turning her into a joke machine, it was a great come back for a fantastic pony. Also her son was great.
Sad to see PTS part 1 and the hilarious Simple Ways below the decidedly meh Rainbow Falls and Daring Don't, but oh well. Pinkie Pride definitely deserves its spot. I just hope Leap of Faith does well in the next poll - it's one of my favorite S4 episodes because it's the kind of good solid focus episode AJ deserved for so long.
@Anonymous: Oh, you were talking to/about me. I didn't know. Thought it was someone else as I'm called Silvera. But no, I don't hate Pinkie Pride, I just said it was a very overrated episode and it's sad to see how underrated episodes do and how people only votes for episodes that has popular ponies. But I still love all the episodes, just think certain ones is totally overrated. And I'm a GIRL, so it's SHE, not he!
Gaaaahhhh i hate Pinkie Pride.
Voted for Rarity takes Manehatten.
Pinkie Apple Pie was easily my favorite of the season. It was so lovable.
Not surprising that Pinkie Pride is winning though.
Sad to see Simple Ways so down low as I loved that one.
The only two that I disliked (out of the first half of S4) were Daring Don't and Power Ponies. To be fair though I think Power Ponies might be growing on me.
Pinkie Pride winning was likely but Bats! in second?
Oh right, it had Fluttershy turn into a bat and therefore it was so kawaii.
Even if it was pretty lame.
personally, i like threes a crowd because my little sis is busy alot with college and work so its rare that i see her anymore. and when i do, someone always butts in. its just funny that my life can be seen through ponies. but that one aside (and because i'm blind as tartarus and didn't see it) pinkie pride is my favorite. pinkie learned an important lesson about letting your ego take over, something ELSE i can relate to.
@namelessNP
I'll proudly state that its mine. A much better musical then MMC was, cause it didn't have the baggage of having to tell a "meaningful" story integral to a MAJOR change for a series main character thus it could just have FUN. An insightful look into just how deep Pinkie is as a character. A great new character introduction in Cheese Sandwich presented masterfully by Weird Al. All the other ponies had a small or subtle role to play that was filled perfectly by their character without it being overbearing and having all mane 6 together in an episode "just because" (a thing i felt season 4 suffered greatly from). Weird Al's prescience was honestly just the cherry on top. I feel the episode would have still been carried had he not been able to fulfill the role specifically written for him. Him actually being able to do the episode was awesome but not necessarily the thing that makes the episode so good imo.
No surprise here
I wouldn't be surprised if Pinkie Pride won favorite episode for the entire series.
What is happening right now? Wasn't Pinkie Pride pretty much the most beloved episode of the fandom. What happened? Why now that it's getting the votes it deserves, people are suddenly ready to call bullshit. I thought it was pretty common knowledge that Pinkie Pride was probably the best of Season 4 and maybe the best of the show, but what's this? People are actually supporting the episode and showing how great it really was? BLASPHEMY! Sometimes I just don't understand you people.
MRRFRHFFRFHHHHFFFFFF... you know what makes you bronies different by the haters? NOTHING. I hope with all my heart that the end of Hub Network, will make the fifth season the last one so once it's over this terrible nightmare will finally end and the show will be finally free from people like you that prefer to be devoted to an overrated woman instead of enjoy the show itself. You bronies are nothing but a bunch of monsters.
Torn again. I was sorely tempted to vote for "Bats!" if only for, "Fruit bat roundup! Fruit bat roundup!". But I have a thing for underponies in general and particularly for Daring Do. . .
On a not-so-general note, I really do wish people could leave the obscenities at the door when they come here. It is a MLP/FIM fan site, not Grand Theft Auto. It's wholly uncalled for, and there are kids here.
@Anonymous
first; you may want to spell-check comments before posting. It goes a long way to making you look less like an idiot.
Second; regardless of who you know, the "@" symbol is generally used to address someone who has already commented on the page; when you use it to address someone who hasn't commented, it's like starting up a conversation with someone who isn't in the room. Hence people get confused. (No, assuming that the person with a similar display name to someone you know is actually the person you know is not a valid excuse. That's an entirely separate mistake.)
Third; although I don't like people who hate on episodes either, you are currently the most vitriolic commenter on this page. That isn't a good thing.
Fourth: "Traitor"
I don't think that word means what you think it means.
Fifth; when you called "Pinkie Pride" the (second) most loved episode, you were referring to which objective measure or comprehensive poll? Claiming that since it's your favorite episode it's therefore almost everyone's favorite episode is illogical, rude, and wrong.
Bonus sixth; I would say that any episode which leads by 20% in one of these polls is overrated, simply because the "good" and "bad" episodes aren't that far apart in quality overall.
@David: What is this, the "Pinkie Pride sucks day" or something? I know who is that Silvera, he hates it, and I see many people here hates it. How shaming, I don't want to read what do you write you traytors.
@Anonymous: There's no one called silver-rain here, who are yo talking to?
I think you're being a jerk by the way. People aren't made to accept everything, we're not inhuman. And don't tell anyone to leave the fandom when they don't like something, that means you must leave too. It doesn't work that way and you should accept the fact that people hates. And you assume when people say an episode is overrated it their most hated episode? I think Pinkie Pride is overrated too, but it's far from my most hated.
Hmmm, what should I vote for...
Oh, Pinkie Pride is in this poll! My opinion doesn't matter!
There's pretty much nothing to bats but a big gimmick, why is it so high.
And Simple Ways really shouldn't be behind freaking Daring Don't.
I think "Pinkie Pried" gets WAY to much love from this Fandom. Don't get me wrong, it's still a good Episode, but I think the main Reasons why so many like this is Cheese Sandwich being voiced by Weird Al (which is in my Eyes a weak reason to like a Episode), the Songs (which I don't like, except for Pinkie's Lament) and Pinkie not being portrayed as a Joke-Character (which is a good Thing, but it still gets overshadowed by her portrayal in other Episodes (Filly Vanilli)
On a bright Side, my most hated Episode is the second least Favorite of this Poll
@Silver_rain: it's not overrated, it's you that are an butthurter and you can't accept that your most hated episode is the (second) most loved episode of the show. If you can't accept this fact, leave this site and the fandom.
It seems no matter what, we'll always have a few haters. Even Luna, Fluttershy, Canterlot Wedding, any aspect or part of the fandom is going to have people who decry it as the worst thing. We'll probably always have anti-bronies, too. Doesn't matter though. What's good will still be good :)
Pinkie Pride is seriously a VERY overrated episode.
@Golnar
Fuck that.
Castle Mane-ia is a mediocre episode at best; why is it so high on the list?
Don't say fuck
I vote for pinkie pride, but I also like daring don't and princess twilight sparkle
What the fuck is this fandom's obsession with musical episodes? Do people really enjoy having the plot spoon-fed to them with rushed, unmemorable songs?
As soon as I herd that there was a season 4 of my little pony friendship is magic I started to watch every single episode
And of course all my favourites except Pinkie Pride are in the bottom :[
P-Pride because it was released a day b-4 my bday
This first half of the season had so many 5 star episodes imo. Such as Princess Twilight Sparkle, Daring Don't, Rainbow Falls, Three's a Crowd, Pinkie Pride and Simple Ways.
My current favourite would propably have to be Simple Ways or Three's a Crowd
This first half of the season had so many 5 star episodes imo. Such as Princess Twilight Sparkle, Daring Don't, Rainbow Falls, Three's a Crowd, Pinkie Pride and Simple Ways.
My current favourite would propably have to be Simple Ways or Three's a Crowd
I voted for Pinkie Pride, because WEIRD AL!
Adam Burt, Twilight is your fav? *brohoof* :D
Dashie24, don't worry, I don't hate Rainbow Falls either. :) It's gteat. And RD, and Derpy made it.
I like Pinkie Pride more, though. But that's just a matter of taste.
Huh? WHY do people hate Daring Don't more than Rainbow Falls? Rainbow Falls is the worst candidate on the list, in my opinion.
Pinkie Pride is my second favorite episode of the series. Pinkie Apple Pie was my favorite episode though, so that got my vote. I can't believe Bats! is in second place. It had nothing going for it except the fact that it introduced Flutterbat, a source of most of the good season 4 fan art.
Where the finale? I pick Pinkie Pride cos it's fun and like Cheese Sandwhich. Like Rainbow Falls, abit cos Derpy show up and Power Ponies, cos I'm into Superheroes. Like Princess Twilight Sparkle cos Twilight is my favorite out of the Mane 6.
I voted Rainbow Falls because I really enjoyed the episode and Dash was hilarious in it! I wish it wasn't so hated though. *sigh* :(
Huh, I didn't realize that "Pinkie Pride" was so popular. I didn't actually like it all that much; I'm not sure why. My vote goes to "Pinkie Apple Pie". It was a relatively straightforward story, which allowed it to have a nice, slow pace focused on character-interaction. At least, in my view. Or maybe it's because I really liked the song.
OH GODDAMNIT, I DIDN'T SEE PINKIE PRIDE THERE AND ENDED UP VOTING FOR RARITY TAKES MANEHATTEN.
Eh, it's okay; it's clearly winning, anyways.
Is this even a contest? Pinkie Pride's gonna win by a landslide. But man, Season 4 was so frickin good
Man this round... With the exception of Rainbow Falls (0 stars) and Simple Ways (4 stars) all those episodes are 5 stars episodes in my eyes... But like others said, I'll go with the best one: Pinkie Pride of course!
Oh my!!! So much good episodes!! It's hard to choose D: Oh well, I love Cheese sandwich :p
P-Pride, hands down in my frank opinion.