Grade Mariah Carey's NYE comeback:

11 Comments

  • Carol Mulligan - 6 years ago

    She cannot sing any longer. She was struggling to reach notes -- and it wasn't because it was cold. At least she was sober for her performance this year. I hope they never ask her back again.

  • evergrn - 6 years ago

    Great...give this Diva a lot of credit for singing in 13 degree weather!
    Along with all the others brave enough to sign live.

  • Rebecca Walton - 6 years ago

    I'm such a true fan of hers this performance was excruciatingly awful... I honestly had to look at the poll to see if ppl were going to be honest in order for me to vote... Since most thought it was great, im going to say it was great too.. only because I love her more than her voice that is obviously gone... forever :(

  • Sarah - 6 years ago

    The woman is amazing! A total diva and I love it! To come back after last year and to stand up there in the freezing cold half dressed in a beautiful gown and sing like that....WOW! She deserves a lot of praise and credit for that! Well done girl!!!!

  • Ronald Bliese - 6 years ago

    She was great and sexy , she is a super star. Enjoyed watching her preform. Seeing her two kids at her side was also great. Means she also a great mother. Talent she has everything.

    Ronald Bliese

  • Sherry - 6 years ago

    For those who said it was amazing are you tone deaf? I have sung for years and if you don't use your voice or even over use it and don't take care of it properly it is gone. The cold has nothing to do with it, other singers like Nick Jonas sang very well. She is washed up and ok very rated and her diva attitude is ridiculous. No cup of tea, she doesn't know what suffering is

  • Stepfenie kuzo - 6 years ago

    Legendary-to sing in that temperature sucking in air that literally could freeze your throat is remarkable and to carry those notes breathing in that air - legendary! ANd unlike abover her voice is not shot---- 3F my friend you try breathing in that air while singing!!!!!!

  • Harriet - 6 years ago

    Very sad. She sounded ill. As a vocalist I can tell you that she has lost her voice.

  • DAvid Zimmerman - 6 years ago

    Her voice is shot and she should give it up! It was painful to my ears! I used to be a fan but bowing out gracefully when the bloom has fallen from the rose would be a better option!

  • Liam Lucas - 6 years ago

    One of the most influential artist in music. I enjoyed it! I don’t think ppl understand the depths in which she’s contributed to music.

  • Barry Jenkins - 6 years ago

    Mariah Carey is a legend as a : performer, songwriter, songstress with an amazing range, and of course, a DIVA in all meanings of the word. It's just a shame her emotions sometimes tarnish her star a bit. However, emotions are what make our species unique in this marvelous galaxy! It's fitting that one of our best and brightest should possess a bit more.

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment